> ## Documentation Index
> Fetch the complete documentation index at: https://adadvisor.ai/docs/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover all available pages before exploring further.

# AdAdvisor Creative Skill: Test and Refresh Meta Ad Creative

> Pick a testing framework (3-2-2, 5-3-1, 3-3-3). Track refresh cadence by spend tier. Preserve social proof on viral Meta (Facebook) posts. Detect creative fatigue before it shows up as CPA inflation.

The **AdAdvisor creative skill** handles testing frameworks, refresh cadence, hook strategy, and the MCP workflow for sourcing assets without losing social proof. Creative drives 70% to 89% of Meta (Facebook) ad performance per AppsFlyer 2025 and Nielsen. Targeting won. Bidding won. Creative is what's left to compete on, and it's also the silent killer when neglected.

## When should I use the creative skill?

Triggers on phrases like:

* "Test ads"
* "Creative"
* "Refresh creatives"
* "Fatigue"
* "What to make next"
* "New creative"
* "Test new hooks"
* "Ads are stale"
* "Swap creative"
* "Upload images"
* "Find images"
* "UGC"

## Which creative testing framework should I use?

The skill picks the right framework based on where you are in the discovery curve:

| Framework | Structure | When to use |
| - | - | - |
| **3-3-3** (Pilothouse) | 3 concepts × 3 formats × 3 hooks = 27 combinations | Brand-new product or angle. Maps the territory. |
| **3-2-2** (Tichenor) | 3 creatives × 2 primary texts × 2 headlines = 12 variants | Established angle. Validates which variant wins. |
| **5-3-1** (Ben & Vic / Motion) | 5 hook variations × 3 body variations × 1 CTA | Post-winner refinement. Milks the angle. |
| **Hook → Body → CTA hierarchy** | Test hooks first (5 to 8 hooks, identical body and CTA). Winner gets iterated bodies, then iterated CTAs. | Methodical buyer with budget. Finds the load-bearing element. |

Tichenor's own September 2025 caveat: "I was wrong about 3:2:2. Meta's Andromeda update changed it. Top advertisers are ramping up creative production, testing multiple concepts per segment." The skill treats 3-2-2 as a floor, not a ceiling.

## How often should I refresh Meta ad creative?

Volume of net-new concepts matters more than total ad count. Brands that produce four new concepts a week beat brands with 50 stale ads.

| Daily spend | Refresh cadence | New concepts per cycle |
| - | - | - |
| $100 to $200 a day | Every 2 to 3 weeks | 1 to 2 |
| $200 to $1,000 a day | Every 7 to 14 days | 2 to 3 |
| $1,000 to $10,000 a day | Every 7 to 10 days | 4 to 6 |
| \$10,000+ a day | Weekly | 4 to 6 net-new |

## How do I read Meta creative performance?

The funnel inherited from [diagnose](https://adadvisor.ai/docs/skills/adadvisor-diagnose.md):

| Metric | Healthy | What it tells you |
| - | - | - |
| Hook Rate (3-sec / impressions) | 25% to 35% | Did people stop scrolling? |
| Hold Rate (15-sec / 3-sec) | 40% to 50% | Did they stay through the body? |
| CTR (link clicks / impressions) | 1.0% to 1.8% | Did the body and CTA convince them to click? |

The skill maps which signal moved to which fix:

* **Hook problem.** Fix the first 1 to 3 seconds. Replace the hook, keep the body.
* **Hold problem.** Fix the transition from hook to body. The hook overpromised or the body was boring.
* **Click problem.** Fix the CTA, value prop, or visual confidence.

## How does the AdAdvisor MCP creative workflow work?

Two paths, depending on whether the asset already exists.

### Path A: reuse or find existing

```
adadvisor:search_ad_images(queries=['...']) → image hashes via the asset picker widget
adadvisor:preview_existing_creatives(image_hash=...) → if has engagement, reuse via existing_post
adadvisor:create_creative(...) → image_link, video, or existing_post format
```

The `preview_existing_creatives` step is critical. Promoting a post with 432 reactions / 87 comments via `existing_post` format preserves that social proof. Uploading the same image as a fresh ad loses it.

### Path B: upload new asset

```
adadvisor:upload_creatives(account_id) → opens upload widget
(widget drives init_upload + S3 PUT + complete_upload internally)
adadvisor:create_creative(...) → with the returned image_hash or video_id
```

Limits: image up to 30 MB, video up to 4 GB. Allowed types: JPEG, PNG, MP4, MOV.

## What aspect ratio and video length should Meta creative use?

| Aspect ratio | Where it lives | Status |
| - | - | - |
| 4:5 (portrait, 1080 × 1350) | Feed (FB + IG) | Default for Feed |
| 9:16 (vertical, 1080 × 1920) | Reels, Stories | Mandatory in 2026 |
| 1:1 (square, 1080 × 1080) | Cross-placement fallback | Safety net |
| 16:9 (horizontal) | Audience Network only | Dead in 2026 |

**Video length sweet spot: 5 to 15 seconds.** Meta auto-loops videos up to 30 seconds for 90 seconds of total view time. Short ads get replayed, accumulating impressions without feeling long.

## What anti-patterns does the creative skill prevent?

> [accordion] Generating creatives without reading brand context
>
> Brand tone, colors, and key selling points live in your AdAdvisor business context. The skill reads them first and grounds every copy recommendation in them.

> [accordion] Reusing image hashes from previous sessions
>
> Image hashes are session-scoped. The skill always fetches fresh via `search_ad_images` or `complete_upload` in the current conversation.

> [accordion] Setting is\_dynamic\_creative: true with 3 ads
>
> Dynamic Creative ad sets accept exactly ONE ad. Multi-variant copy lives in that one creative's `messages`, `headlines`, and `descriptions` arrays (max 5 each).

> [accordion] Killing a creative after 24 hours
>
> Defers to the diagnose skill's kill rule: 3x target CPA with zero conversions over the right account-size window.

> [accordion] Re-uploading a viral organic post as a fresh ad
>
> Loses the social proof. The skill uses `format: 'existing_post'` with the post URL or `object_story_id` instead.

> [accordion] Building 16:9 horizontal videos for Reels
>
> Letterboxed with black bars. The skill requires 9:16 for Reels and Stories placements and 4:5 for Feed.

## How do I install the creative skill?

> [card] [Claude Code](https://adadvisor.ai/docs/skills/install-claude-code.md)
>
> Ships with the full plugin install.

> [card] [Claude.ai & Desktop](https://adadvisor.ai/docs/skills/install-claude.md)
>
> Download [adadvisor-creative.zip](https://github.com/AdAdvisor/skills/releases/latest/download/adadvisor-creative.zip) and upload via Settings, Capabilities, Skills.

## Frequently asked questions

> [accordion] What is the 3-2-2 creative testing framework?
>
> Charley Tichenor's framework. 3 creatives × 2 primary texts × 2 headlines = 12 dynamic variants in one Meta ad set. Use Dynamic Creative to auto-optimize the combination. Best for validating which variation of a proven angle wins. For brand-new angles use 3-3-3 (Pilothouse) instead.

> [accordion] How often should I refresh Meta ad creative?
>
> Spend-dependent. $100 to $200 a day, refresh every 2 to 3 weeks (1 to 2 new concepts). $1,000 to $10,000 a day, refresh every 7 to 10 days (4 to 6 new). \$10,000+ a day, refresh weekly with 4 to 6 net-new concepts. Volume of new concepts matters more than total ad count.

> [accordion] How do I preserve social proof when promoting a viral Instagram or Facebook post?
>
> Use `format: 'existing_post'` in `adadvisor:create_creative`, passing either the `instagram_post_url`, `facebook_post_url`, or `object_story_id`. The skill calls `preview_existing_creatives` first to check engagement counts. Posts with 100+ reactions get promoted via `existing_post` to preserve likes, comments, and shares. Posts without organic engagement get uploaded fresh.

> [accordion] What is hook rate and what counts as good?
>
> Hook rate is 3-second views divided by impressions. The percentage of viewers who stopped scrolling long enough to count as having seen the ad. Healthy is 25% to 35% on Meta prospecting. Strong is 30% to 45%. Under 20% means the first 1 to 3 seconds need work.

> [accordion] Is 16:9 horizontal video still useful for Meta ads in 2026?
>
> Generally no. Reels and Stories placements (where most attention is in 2026) require 9:16 vertical. Feed prefers 4:5 portrait. 16:9 only survives on Audience Network and gets letterboxed everywhere else, which suppresses delivery. The creative skill rejects 16:9 for Reels and Stories campaigns.

> [accordion] Can I use Dynamic Creative with a lead form?
>
> No. Meta does not yet allow `is_dynamic_creative: true` ad sets to pair with `lead_gen_form_id`. The skill catches this and either turns off Dynamic Creative or routes lead-form creatives through standard single-variant copy.

## Related skills

> [card] [Launch](https://adadvisor.ai/docs/skills/adadvisor-launch.md)
>
> Pairs with launch when creative is part of a new campaign.

> [card] [Diagnose](https://adadvisor.ai/docs/skills/adadvisor-diagnose.md)
>
> Diagnose surfaces creative fatigue. This skill handles the refresh.

> [card] [Targeting](https://adadvisor.ai/docs/skills/adadvisor-targeting.md)
>
> Sarah Levinger's "creative does the targeting" thesis lives at the intersection of these two.


This documentation is built and hosted on [Mintlify](https://mintlify.com), a developer documentation platform.